OUR REVIEW & Highlights

​

If you are looking for the quintessence of "island time" on Elbow Cay, Firefly Bar & Grill at the Firefly Sunset Resort is widely considered the premier spot for sunset views and upscale-yet-relaxed Bahamian dining.

 

Located just south of Hope Town, Firefly manages to strike a balance between a lively social hub and a romantic getaway. Here is a breakdown of what makes it a standout on the island.

 

The Atmosphere & Views

True to its name, the sunset is the main event here. The restaurant is positioned perfectly to watch the sun dip below the Sea of Abaco.

 

• Vibe: It’s "barefoot chic." You’ll see people coming off their boats in salt-stained linen next to families and couples dressed up for a nice dinner.

• Setting: Most of the seating is open-air, allowing for the harbor breeze. The deck is expansive, and if you arrive early, grabbing a seat at the bar with a view of the water is a must.

• The Food: Fresh & Flavorful

 

The menu focuses heavily on locally sourced seafood with a modern twist, though they are also famous for their Southern-inspired comfort food.

 

The Highlights:

• Firefly Lobster Quesadilla: Frequently cited as a fan favorite; it’s rich, cheesy, and packed with fresh Abaco lobster.

• Cracked Conch: A Bahamian staple done exceptionally well here—tender and lightly battered.

• The Firefly Burger: For those who need a break from seafood, their burgers are consistently rated as some of the best in the Abacos.

• Sunday Brunch: If you’re on the island over the weekend, don’t miss their Bahamian Brunch. It features traditional dishes like "boil fish" and stew conch, alongside homemade conch salad.

 

The Drinks:

Given that the resort is owned by the creators of Firefly Sweet Tea Vodka, the cocktail menu is a highlight.

Signature Sips: Try the "Fly-Guy" or any of the Sweet Tea Vodka infusions. They are dangerously easy to drink in the heat.

Local Vibes: They also keep plenty of cold Sands and Kalik on hand for those who prefer a local brew.

 

Practical Tips:

• Reservations: For dinner, reservations are strongly recommended, especially during the peak season (March–July). Lunch and breakfast are generally first-come, first-served.

• Accessibility: Most visitors arrive via golf cart (they have plenty of parking) or by boat (they offer dockage for diners).

• Kids & Pets: It is very family-friendly, featuring a dedicated kids' menu and plenty of space for them to move around. It is also one of the more pet-friendly spots on the cay.

​

Final Verdict: Whether you’re staying at the resort or just navigating down from Hope Town in a golf cart, Firefly is an essential Elbow Cay experience. It’s a bit pricier than some of the smaller shacks, but the combination of the view, the vodka, and the lobster quesadillas makes it worth every penny.